The best argument for
the president or the former president's
immunity claim is that even though the Supreme Court has not Grappled with this precise issue
that is can a president be criminally
prosecuted
for
official acts within the ambit of his executive responsibilities.
The court has grappled with an analogous situation involving
President Nixon in the early
1980s, which involved a civil lawsuit.
And I think the strong argument should be that
the same rationale that the court had for saying the president needed to be spared from civil liability
applies especially nowadays when we have very politicized
prosecutions
to
the criminal ambit as well because what you don't want to have as a president when he's making the most important decisions that have to be made for the national security of the United States, to be worrying about
when he's out of power, whether it's civil lawsuits
or criminal indictments brought by
justice departments from the opposition party
that has policy disagreements,
you don't want the president worrying about future liability while he's trying to make the best decision for the country.
Sure.
So 1 of the distinctions that we heard in the back and forth here was the question
about
the actual
issue at hand for which the president is seeking immunity. And they talked about President Obama using drones and drone strikes that killed civilians
in terms of whether or not a president is immune from any prosecution with regard to that. There's another issue with regard to George W. Bush in the actions
of president
and immunity
from
committing murder, for example,
in these cases, because he's carrying out national security issues. But we heard some of their line of questioning
leaning towards...
What?